Arthur Conan Doyle defends his spiritualist beliefs
DOYLE, Arthur Conan (1859-1930). Lengthy ALS (4 pp.) to Reverend George Bainton, 3 July 1919, signed in full, with original envelope addressed in Doyle's hand. [With] Life After Death, 4 pp.; 20.4 x 12.6 cm, a rare leaflet published by the author in December 1918, Green & Gibson B24. Both letter and leaflet are tipped into a copy of The Case for Spirit Photography (New York: George H. Doran, 1923), First American Edition, Very good. Green & Gibson B31b.
The Case for Spirit Photography is one of the most quixotic of Doyle’s major publications. The book was written in response to a charge of fraud leveled by skeptic Harry Price against a group of spiritualists in Crewe centered on the mediumship of William Hope and Mrs. Buxton, who allegedly were able to cause by psychic means likenesses of the deceased to appear in photographic plates. Price, a stage magician and a debunker, invited the pair to demonstrate their powers in February 1922, and swiftly exposed the humbug, publishing the results in the Journal of the Society for Psychical Research. Outraged, Doyle defended Hope and Buxton and lambasted both Price and the SPR, accusing them of conspiracy and deception with intent to destroy the reputation of an honorable man. The book was published in wrappers by Hutchinson in December 1922, and issued in hardcover in the United States in January 1923.
The introduction is by Fred Barlow, who served as the secretary of Society for the Study of Supernormal Pictures (SSSP), an assemblage of some of the most credulous minds of England, “I do not see how we can possibly get away from the fact that many of these photographic effects are produced by discarnate intelligences,” he wrote. By the time the book was issued, Doyle had spent several years defending the Crewe circle. He mentions Hope and Buxton first in The Vital Message (1919), which was originally serialized in Hearst's International from March to November 1919.
Tipped in to the first American edition of The Case for Spirit Photography is Doyle’s lengthy and intemperate letter to the Reverend George Bainton (1847-1925). Bainton was a Congregationalist minister in Coventry, and the author of several works, including The Art of Authorship: Literary Reminiscences, Methods of Work, and Advice to Young Beginners, Personally Contributed by Leading Authors of the Day (1890). In addition to Doyle, he corresponded also with Grieg, Tchaikovsky, Rimsky-Korsakov, William Morris, and Thomas Hardy.
Bainton has also tipped in a very rare ephemeron, a four-page leaflet that Doyle published in December 1918 to reply to the hundreds of inquiries he received after publication of The New Revelation (1918). The leaflet, which is headed with Doyle's address, opens with a two-page letter offering his recommendations for further reading on psychic phenomena. The latter pages reprint an article "Life After Death," published originally in the Daily Chronicle on 5 November 1918.
In his four-page letter to Bainton, Doyle offers both an attack on established religion (“my experience is that the collective churches are both ignorant & hostile”), and a vigorous defense of Mrs. [Annie] B[rittain], who had recently been the subject of an exposé in the weekly magazine Truth. Doyle defends Brittain’s criminal record (“of course any paid medium is liable to conviction by the present barbarous laws, so that there is nothing in that”), explains away her false results (“when interviewed by a bogus client that is absolutely to be expected since every law of harmony is broken”), and points out that out of the forty-eight clients he sent to her (!), forty “have had complete satisfaction.”
Mrs. Buxton (upper right) with her daughter and the spirit of her father
Offering some general remarks of support for the Spiritualist movement, Doyle explains, “I send you this long explanation that you may disabuse the minds of those of your congregation who were taken in by ‘Truth’s’ bogus exposure.” Doyle would offer a very similar defense of Mrs. Brittain in Appendix D of The Vital Message (1919), which he must have written shortly after his letter to Rev. Bainton. Several years later Doyle’s devotion to spiritualism in general and spirit photography in particular would again come under attack, this time in the form of a blast from Houdini, A Magician among the Spirits (1924).
Product tabs
SOLD
Earn 0Reward points
Recommend this product

Arthur Conan Doyle defends his spiritualist beliefs
Related products
A jumbo Gillette Marketing Portfolio from the Mad Men era
Gillette Safety Razor Company. The Mighty Midget. Advertising presentation portfolio. [Boston: Gillette Safety Razor Company, ca. 1953]. 33 leaves, pr...
view details
$1,400
View details
$25,000
A richly detailed diary of Gold Rush California 1850-1852
Pangborn, David Knapp (1803-1874). Manuscript journal, 1850-1852, 1862-1864. 256 pp.; about 6½ x 8½ in. Bound in original calf journal with contrastin...
view details
$25,000
View details
$0
Joseph Lindon Smith: A Famous Artist Trifles with a Boston Debutante
Smith, Joseph Lindon (1863-1950). Seven letters to Margaret (“Margetta”) Wesselhoeft (1888- 1947), with one original envelope. The letters are bifol...
view details
$0
View details
$0
Philip Schuyler, Autograph Letter Signed to Richard Varick on the war in Quebec and his slave, Prince, 1776.
Schuyler, Philip (1733 – 1804). Autograph Letter Signed to Richard Varick (1753 – 1831) on the war in Quebec and his slave, Prince. Fort George, May 2...
view details
$0
View details
$950
Distributing bibles in Texas and Mexico
Powell, William D[avid] (1854 – 1934) and G[eorge] J[ames] Johnson (1824 – 1902). Correspondence archive. 10 letters from Johnson to Powell, 1882 to 1...
view details
$950
View details
$12,500
Stefan Zweig. Nine letters to Felix Wittmer, 1930-1937
Zweig, Stefan (1881 – 1942). A file of nine typed letters to the writer Felix Wittmer (1902 – 1985). 13 pp. total, with holograph corrections and sign...
view details
$12,500
View details
$0
Merle Armitage, An archive of correspondence and ephemera, 1924-1962
Armitage, Merle (1893-1975). An important archive of materials pertaining to the one of the most important graphic designers of the twentieth century,...
view details
$0
View details
$385
A letter from Tahitian missionary George Pritchard to his daughter (1841)
Pritchard, George (1796-1883). ALS to his daughter, Elizabeth ("Eliza") Sarah Pritchard, Surrey Chapel House, 17 November 1841. 2 p. A short let...
view details
$385
View details
$1,350
A San Francisco judge starts in Cleveland (1849-1850)
Cowles, Samuel (1823-1880). Diary, July 1849 to July 1850. About 50 pages, written in a clear, easily legible hand with a few lines in Pitman's shorth...
view details
$1,350
View details
$17,500
A Great American Songbook: Ann Stewart's Revolutionary hymnal, c.1767 to 1789
Stewart, Ann (ca. 1741 – 1821) Manuscript Musical Notebook, Cheltenham, Pennsylvania, circa 1767-1789. 4 ¼ x 8 ½ in. 86 pp. on 45 leaves (two blank). ...
view details
$17,500
View details
$9,500
A memoir of the Black Hawk War and the Founding of Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin (1833)
Smith, Henry (1798 – 1847), Indian Campaign of 1832. Holograph manuscript, 1833. 18 pp. 10 x 8 inches, approximately 4500 words. Authorial corrections...
view details
$9,500
View details
$2,750
Signed typescript for a coded play by Lynn Riggs, queer Cherokee nationalist
Riggs, [Rolla] Lynn (1899-1954). A World Elsewhere, carbon typescript, circa 1943-1947. The author has written his name, address (1 Christopher Street...
view details
$2,750
View details
$1,750
The nature diary of a Walt Whitman enthusiast and "literary light man," 1896-1897
Elliot, Charles Nathan (1873-1951). Sylvan Notes. Manuscript journal, April 19, 1896 to Oct. 10, 1897. 190 p.; ill.; 172 x 102 mm (6 ¾ x 4 in). Origin...
view details
$1,750
View details
$1,450
An 1850s album amicorum from St. Mary’s Academy and Notre Dame
Byerley, Josephine (1835 – 1896). Souvenir Album. South Bend, Indiana, 1852 – 1857. 7 x 8 in. At least 45 pages of holograph poetry, remembrances, and...
view details
$1,450
View details
$1,450
Friderike Zweig, letters on Hannah Arendt and other matters, 1935 to 1953
Zweig, Friderike Maria (1882 – 1971). A small collection of letters and enclosures, including an ALS to Toni Strassman (2 pp.), and and four ALS and A...
view details
$1,450
View details
$0
An Italian Manuscript on Physics, with Discussion of Benjamin Franklin
BARTALONI, Domenico (1726-1798). Physicae tam Generalis, quam Particularis. Tractatus decem hoc uno Comprehensio Volumine. A Dominico Bartaloni elabor...
view details
$0
View details
$850
Gold Diggers of 1932: Pelham Humphries's Heirs during the Great Depression
[Spindletop] A collection of about 100 pieces of correspondence between claimants to the Pelham Humphries fortune, from the files of W[alter] T[homas]...
view details
$850
View details
$45,000
Thomas Paine. Common Sense. The first London edition (1776), completed in manuscript
Paine, Thomas (1737-1809). Common Sense; Addressed to the Inhabitants of America… A New Edition, with several Additions in the Body of the Work. To wh...
view details
$45,000
View details
$4,500
Class notes from the first years of the American Academy of Dramatic Arts
Sargent, Franklin Haven (1856 – 1924) and Ida Ellen Serven (1859 – 1928), Pantomime, class notes by Kathryn A. Fischer (1859 – 1939). Manuscript noteb...
view details
$4,500
View details
$7,500
Poems by a Uranian from the American heartland, inscribed to a favorite
Bellamy, Orlando Rollin (1856 – 1911). Poems, 1892-94. Two volumes. 295 + 295 pp. Collecting a total 352 poems in holograph, with indexes, copied in t...
view details
$7,500
View details